Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

it seems to suck that the page is deleted out-right. I would rather that the page altered to reveal that it was all a hoax, but still describe the ficticious person, and perhaps also describe how the hoax was perpetrated. Those tidbits are rather interesting, and would be a shame to have all been lost in the next few decades.


I agree.

It's interesting to note that Wikipedia does this for other pages that were "based on real facts" or were hoaxes. The one that comes to mind right away is Blair Witch.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Blair_Witch_Project

The movie's official website featured fake police reports and "newsreel-style" interviews. These augmented the movie's found footage style to spark debates across the internet over whether the movie was a real-life documentary or a work of fiction.[30]

Apparently when its their OX getting gored its not ok.


Articles about hoaxes need to meet same notability standards as other Wikipedia articles. If other newspapers write widely about the Gadyukin article and it becomes a famous example, then an article about it will presumably be created.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Do_not_create_hoaxes...



This raises the question, could Wikipedia reference itself in the past when it's an historical article about itself?


I would guess not, That would constitute original research or perhaps a primary source.

Rather than reference itself it would prefer to refer to sources that refer back to Wikipedia.


Is there an archive of deleted Wikipedia pages, or are they gone forever?



Nice one, thanks. What I meant was, do Wikipedia themselves keep an archive or are the articles basically zapped forever?


It appears that Wikipedia does keep an archive ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Viewing_and_restorin...

However ...

> A message by Wikipedia system administrator Brion Vibber from January 2007 warned that deleted revisions could theoretically be cleared without warning at any time, and a script exists to perform this function. However in practice they have only been cleared twice, both times due to technical issues – once on 3 December 2003, because the Wikipedia database was transferred to a new server, and once on 8 June 2004 due to a database crash.

This is, of course, different from the revision history for an article, which shows each edit and is available for public inspection, e.g., ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Deep_learning&off...


>Only administrators, checkusers, and oversighters can view the content of deleted pages.

Almost, but no cigar :(




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: