Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Can you really say that unless you switched fields multiple times?

I have ;-) far too many times! Even going back and taking undergrad math coursework that my engineering curriculum didn't have like Discrete Math or Statistics got a lot harder than calculus / differential equations was when I was younger. I felt like I got less out of each hour, and also couldn't put in as many hours - not just because I have more responsibilities, but also because my brain just gets tired after fewer hours.



>my brain just gets tired after fewer hours.

Have you tried creatine supplements? Especially if you're vegan or don't eat a lot of meat. Most people take it for muscle performance, but I found it insanely helpful for maintaining a sharp mind throughout a long day, especially with little sleep. That's also what the latest research starts to appreciate. I wouldn't be surprised to see recommended doses above 10g/day in elderly soon-ish since there are basically zero downsides even at much higher doses. In my early 30s I thought I lost my ability to pull all nighters because of increased tiredness, but now I feel like I can do even more than when I was 18. Most people greatly underestimate diet in general because they used to get away with anything when they were young.


Counterpoint: I've been taking creatine (10-15mg/day) for over 8 months and I can't say that I notice a difference at all.

That said, while I think that creatine's effects on cognitive performance are often overstated, creatine is scientifically proven to increase brain performance in some cases[1].

And fortunately, creatine is safe and very cheap[2], so maybe worth a try.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creatine#Cognitive_performance

2. https://www.bulksupplements.com/products/creatine-monohydrat...


Did you have problems with tiredness and concentrating? Especially after only getting very little sleep for an extended time? Or did you already consume a lot of meat? There are many factors here that could potentially make it not worth your while. As with all supplements, a good diet and lots of rest can make them little more than expensive pee. But not everyone can have a perfect diet and lots of sleep all the time. Creatine is a supplement for a very particular lifestyle.


Yep, I bet you're exactly right.

> Did you have problems with tiredness and concentrating?

Yes. Still do.

> Especially after only getting very little sleep for an extended time?

No

> Or did you already consume a lot of meat?

Yes. I mean, I probably eat less meat than the average American, but certainly plenty. Beef, too (high in creatine).

> As with all supplements, a good diet and lots of rest can make them little more than expensive pee.

Yep, this probably describes me. It's still pretty cheap, so I still do it (especially since my kids take creatine as well).


>> Especially after only getting very little sleep for an extended time?

>No

Then I'm not really surprised. I also see no real cognitive effects when everything is well anyways. But this one study is what I found to be the most accurate finding overall beyond enhancing muscle power:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10902318/

It's also super easy to test yourself.


Hell even my young brain got tired on statistics and algebra. Could part of this also be field mismatch?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: