Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes!

Have you every heard a heroin addict comparing heroin to TV?





No but everyone has been or has known someone who rages when they lose access to their videogames, and everyone knows someone who has played videogames to the point that it is detrimental to their school or work obligations.

You can replace "videogames" with literally anything and it still works.

Sports, dance, family, etc.

Everybody knows too many people for an anecdote to make videogames and heroin the same. It's like pointing out some school shooter played a violent video games; so did the people they shot. You need to disprove the null hypothesis; not show that there exists evidence.


> You can replace "videogames" with literally anything and it still works.

That's like saying "one who cannot go without food is the same as one who is addicted to heroin." You're engaging in superficiality to the point that all distinction is made meaningless.

> It's like pointing out some school shooter played a violent video games

That's a totally different argument


>You're engaging in superficiality to the point that all distinction is made meaningless

Yes, that's the point.

>That's a totally different argument

Not really. It's the Millenial equivalent the satanic rock scare. Politicians will always use these kinds of tricks to influence opinion and even enact laws.

I want more than sound bites if we're going to compare addiction to something as well studied as hard drugs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: