Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What exactly is a "properly left party" that we don't have?

Is that like the meme on how communism isn't bad, because we never had "real communism"?





No. More like central or Western European parties. Or Green in the UK. Most left-wing politicians in America would seem right wing in, for example, Netherlands.

I think bringing communism into the discussion around left wing parties is as daft as saying all republicans or Tories are Nazis.

The problem with the UK and US is we’re so used to right wing policies that anything moderately left is considered “extreme”. There’s no nuance left because people are closed off to it. (And to be fair, may left wing folk don’t help when they call their right wing peers “racists”. There definitely needs to be more tolerance on both sides)


>No. More like central or Western European parties.

That couldn't be more vague. That's like saying I want a car like the ones in that parking lot over there.

You have no idea that some parties in Poland, Hungary or Romania would make Donald Trump look left wing.

When I asked you what type of left parties you claim are lacking, I expected to hear the exact policies you want but are lacking, not pointing at random parties that not everyone knows.

And we've have enough left wing and green policies in Europe since they're the ones who championed the "refugees welcome" open borders problem, gas dependence on Russian gas and denuclearisation.


> That couldn't be more vague.

That’s why I then gave examples ;)

> You have no idea that some parties in Poland, Hungary or Romania would make Donald Trump look left wing.

You’re now talking about nationalist parties.

But yes, I do agree that there are right wing leaning counties in Central Europe as well.

To be honest, it feels like the whole world is heading that way right now.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: