I was really hoping this would at last be a treatment of the most realistic risk for AI, but no.
The real risk -- and all indicators are that this is already underway -- is that OpenAI and a few others are going to position themselves to be the brokers for most of human creative output, and everyone's going to enthusiastically sign up for it.
Centralization and a maniacal focus on market capture and dominance have been the trends in business for the last few decades. Along the way they have added enormous pressures on the working classes, increasing performance expectations even as they extract even more money from employees' work product.
As it stands now, more and more tech firms are expecting developers to use AI tools -- always one of the commercial ones -- in their daily workflows. Developers who don't do this are disadvantaged in a competitive job market. Journalism, blogging, marketing, illustration -- all are competing to integrate commercial AI services into their processes.
The overwhelming volume of slop produced by all this will pollute our thinking and cripple the creative abilities of the next generation of people, all the while giving these handful of companies a percentage cut of global GDP.
I'm not even bearish on the idea of integrating AI tooling into creative processes. I think there are healthy ways to do it that will stimulate creativity and enrich both the creators and the consumers. But that's not what's happening.
The real risk -- and all indicators are that this is already underway -- is that OpenAI and a few others are going to position themselves to be the brokers for most of human creative output, and everyone's going to enthusiastically sign up for it.
Centralization and a maniacal focus on market capture and dominance have been the trends in business for the last few decades. Along the way they have added enormous pressures on the working classes, increasing performance expectations even as they extract even more money from employees' work product.
As it stands now, more and more tech firms are expecting developers to use AI tools -- always one of the commercial ones -- in their daily workflows. Developers who don't do this are disadvantaged in a competitive job market. Journalism, blogging, marketing, illustration -- all are competing to integrate commercial AI services into their processes.
The overwhelming volume of slop produced by all this will pollute our thinking and cripple the creative abilities of the next generation of people, all the while giving these handful of companies a percentage cut of global GDP.
I'm not even bearish on the idea of integrating AI tooling into creative processes. I think there are healthy ways to do it that will stimulate creativity and enrich both the creators and the consumers. But that's not what's happening.