Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> except that for a majority of users, windows is where their applications are at - such as gaming, word processing, or some other thing.

Until you switch to linux you won't understand how inferior your windows setup always was.

It's hard for us to tell you what you are missing out on, you simply need to experience it.

I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to Linux workspace.

This is not because Linux gaming is horrible broken, but rather it gives me a fully separate leisure desktop, and my main Linux desktop is work only.

It also gives me 100% compatibility, unlike wine.

> People who say "just switch" to linux hasn't done it for their family/friends.

When we say so here, we are telling you to switch.

Nobody should be forcing anything on friends/family.

I always suggest MacOS for friends/family for ease of support. I would never recommend Windows to anyone.



> I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to Linux workspace.

Apologies for hopping on this thread with off topic question, but would you mind describing your setup?

I haven’t tried this in years, but last time I did I had trouble getting pass-through to some of my hardware, in particular my nvidia card.

Agree with your approach 100%!



Thank you! ^_^


> I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to Linux workspace.

> This is not because Linux gaming is horrible broken, but rather it gives me a fully separate leisure desktop, and my main Linux desktop is work only.

> It also gives me 100% compatibility, unlike wine.

You would get a fully separate leisure desktop if you were running Linux in that VM so it sounds like you are running Windows in the VM because Linux gaming is not adequate.


I'm not the person you replied to, but I'm in a situation where I want GPU passthrough to Linux guests. The problem is that the Looking Glass guest application for linux is unmaintained. This makes it impossible to have the same setup but with a linux guest instead of Windows.

If you want to have GPU accelerated video output from a guest vm to a linux host, the only way is with a Windows guest (to the best of my knowledge). If you just need compute then that is different.


Looking Glass is old. See https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/PCI_passthrough_via_OVMF for direct GPU passthrough.

Assuming your graphic card is supported by linux, it will work just fine.


Of course it depends on what you're playing, but VM gaming is not 100% compatible, lots of anti cheats will ban VM users and it's a cat and mouse game to not get detected.


Indeed. But those anti cheat usually also don't allow Wine.

I don't pay for anti consumer tech like kernel mode anti cheat harmware.


Can you comment more on your VM setup? Can it utilize the GPU properly? Any performance or compatibility issues with running windows in a VM? Etc.


It is maybe 95% of native performance or in that ballpark, according to benchmarks I've seen.

I have a dedicated M2 disk that I pass thru fully to the Windows VM in order to have snappy disk, and I reserved 64 GB ram to that VM alone using hugepages (because I multibox a old game that requires lots of RAM for my use case).

I also pass thru the bluetooth hardware into the VM as I don't use bluetooth on my host, so that I can use my dualsense controller while gaming in the VM.


Many popular games have anticheats that prevent vm use.


Don't pay for software that prevents you from using your computer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: