Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Nope, not yet, this post dropped three pages in 5 minutes. I guess someone's feefees got hurt.


It's on the front page now.

Don't confuse a snapshot for a trajectory.


The comment pointing out that this story is flagged is itself flagged, for some reason.

Since you might have showdead off, I'll repeat the point.

And to add to the point, this isn't a snapshot. It's a trajectory. Look at my favorites for a list of good, important stories which were flagged here lately.

Look at PG and Garry Tan's Twitters, where they praise the DOGE team. Look at the point-blank refusal of the mod team here to permit a discussion on these false flags in their own thread, rather than just in comments. You don't need to be a savant to notice the pattern here.


If it was the trajectory you're talking about, it would have stayed off the front page after you saw it down lower in the ranking.

There's a lot of stochastic behavior in the ranking of posts based on when people see them and how many of them upvote or comment. Always has been.


Ah, I thought you were referring to this story as 'the snapshot' and HN as a whole as 'the trajectory'.


> Nope, not yet, this post dropped three pages in 5 minutes. I guess someone's feefees got hurt.

Please refrain from nonsense HN conspiracy theories. The HN algorithm is and has always been designed to encourage good behavior on the site, favoriting the overall health of discussion on the site over any particular topic and penalizing pages where participants interact poorly. Yes, that means many important topics get automatically downranked because the participants in those topics disagree on the topic strongly enough to engage in upvote/downvote wars and other signals of bad conversational behavior. That is an acknowledged result of the long term algoritm design.

HN has been very clear over the years that their primary goal is for people to debate interesting topics well here, and the overall quality of discussion on HN compared to other sites suggests there is some validity to their approach.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: