1. That's not the trade that's happening. Every person in the US is paying for their own health insurance. Having Aetna tell you your claim is denied because someone else needed a heart transplant makes no sense. Also this is unrelated but the whole "years of quality of life" is such a made up bullshit thing it's laughable. It's reasonable on the physician end especially when treatments have hard recoveries but for the insurance end it's ridiculous. Can you imagine your car insurance not paying out after an accident because they decided you don't have enough years driving left? That's just patently not your job to evaluate.
2. For most treatments the fight with insurance happens after the services are rendered and even when you do get prior auths they're not binding so that's always fun for people. The money is already being paid, the only question is who.
3. Doctors aren't given absolute power under this system, they're still limited by all the same restrictions they had before—medical board, government regulations, standards of care—except there isn't a private 3rd party with a direct financial incentive to deny care inserting themselves in the middle.
1. That's not the trade that's happening. Every person in the US is paying for their own health insurance. Having Aetna tell you your claim is denied because someone else needed a heart transplant makes no sense. Also this is unrelated but the whole "years of quality of life" is such a made up bullshit thing it's laughable. It's reasonable on the physician end especially when treatments have hard recoveries but for the insurance end it's ridiculous. Can you imagine your car insurance not paying out after an accident because they decided you don't have enough years driving left? That's just patently not your job to evaluate.
2. For most treatments the fight with insurance happens after the services are rendered and even when you do get prior auths they're not binding so that's always fun for people. The money is already being paid, the only question is who.
3. Doctors aren't given absolute power under this system, they're still limited by all the same restrictions they had before—medical board, government regulations, standards of care—except there isn't a private 3rd party with a direct financial incentive to deny care inserting themselves in the middle.