Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Before flagging, please consider how this act has not been invoked since WW2. Therefore it is a novel and worthy of discussion, regardless of how "not technology related" it is.


These don’t get flagged because they aren’t “technology related”


I think the common reasons are: Not worthy of HN discussion; (claimed to) likely to devolve into unrelated/heated arguments, and against HN rules.

Just that I don't agree this topic fit in any of those categories, so just want to state it first.


I mean, it trivially fits a number of them but a really big one is 'repetition'. Various political and other not-entirely-HN-on-topic stories end up on the front page and have threads but these are exceptions for particularly unusual or big ones. An administration that engages in daily shitposting-through-executive-order gets a couple of these for novelty but the novelty has long worn off - you'd have to fill HN with them if they all counted as exceptional.

Of course, if you think this one deserves special treatment, the thing to do is email hn@ycombinator.com and ask for flags to be taken off. I think in this case it's a little uphill (as another toplevel comment points out - the news has already overtaken this thing) and you'd probably need to find some sort of third party reporting rather than the government press release.


From my observation, the only topic that will definitely be flagged before any discussions is genocide in Gaza…


I think you're being very generous in your beliefs about why people flag these sort of stories.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: