Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Have they revoked it? I thought he’s just been arrested. That’s something various police forces within State absolutely can do with probably cause.


Does it matter if he was 'arrested'? They didn't and are not following proper protocol. There was no warrant for his arrest, he's being denied his right to an attorney and are refusing to tell his representation where he is even at.


> They didn't and are not following proper protocol. There was no warrant for his arrest

Again, police don’t need a warrant with probable cause.

> he's being denied his right to an attorney

Source? His attorney is quoted in the article.

> refusing to tell his representation where he is even at

Source? The article states he’s at “an immigration detention facility in Elizabeth, New Jersey.”

There are obvious First Amendment and free speech issues with this arrest. Those get diluted if folks start making things up about the severity of the situation.


> Again, police don’t need a warrant with probable cause.

Yes you do. You can not just barge into someones home and perform an illegal search + arrest without extreme probable cause.. And nothing they say would rise to that level of arresting someone solely on probable cause because there's no clear imminent threat of violence. They were not able to produce a warrant.

> Source? His attorney is quoted in the article.

https://bsky.app/profile/premthakker.bsky.social/post/3ljxt6... [1]

It takes all of five minutes to get the latest update. His attorney does not know where he's being held and no one is allowed to visit him.

[1] https://www.foxnews.com/us/ice-agents-arrest-anti-israel-act... (the related Fox News article)


> Yes you do. You can not just barge into someones home and perform an illegal search + arrest

Search and arrest, yes. If police see probable cause to arrest from the street, they can arrest.

> because there's no clear imminent threat of violence

Violence is unnecessary. If you’re caught shoplifting, the cop can arrest you without a warrant even if you weren’t violent.

> His attorney does not know where he's being held and no one is allowed to visit him

The tweet is from 9 hours ago. (Who is the source?)

The article is newer. We know where he is.


> The article is newer. We know where he is.

Okay then tell me: Where is he being held? Here's a quote from his attorney:

> "Currently, we do not know Mahmoud’s precise whereabouts. Initially, we were informed this morning that he had been transferred to an ICE facility in Elizabeth, New Jersey," Greer added.

> "However, when his wife – a U.S. citizen who is eight months’ pregnant and was threatened with arrest as well by the ICE agents last night – tried to visit him there today, she was told he is not detained there."


Where are you getting these quotes? From when?


I literally posted the article in my post that you responded to. Did you not read it before just jumping in to respond that you knew where he was being held?


So it’s the same hours-old quote?


> There are obvious First Amendment and free speech issues with this arrest.

Unlikely. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harisiades_v._Shaughnessy


The parallel AP article (https://apnews.com/article/columbia-university-mahmoud-khali...) says he is no longer in New Jersey and may have been moved to Louisiana. It also says (implies?) that neither his wife nor his lawyer have been in touch with him nor know where he is being kept.


> It also says (implies?) that neither his wife nor his lawyer have been in touch with him nor know where he is being kept

Thank you. This is concerning. I’ll keep an eye out for a statement from the lawyer. It may be that nobody is telling the press while the internet runs with the meme.


ICE agents told his lawyer (in a phone call while he was being arrested) that it had been revoked




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: