Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How doed charging executives in addition to fining a company an amount that puts the card company into unresolvable bankruptcy lead to "diffusion of responsibility"?

Yeah, rich CEOs and investors are opposed to taking any responsibility for their actions, but that doesn't we shouldn't try to hold them responsible.



It doesn’t lead to a diffusion of responsibility, the diffusion exists independently by nature of how a business operates.

A CEO will green light high level strategic direction, but the crimes described here could easily emerge from the implementation of that directive at lower levels of the company. “Plausible deniability”


The CEO in that case would be culpable for culturing a culture of criminality.

The buck stops at the top.


I mean, I agree with the sentiment but good luck codifying that in a law that won’t be abused to convict innocent people who were convenient patsies while letting guilty ones walk free due to the “subjective” nature.


Sarbanes Oxley already codifies corporate officer responsibility into law, so there's a pretty clear precedent.


Does Sarbanes Oxley codify culturing a culture?

As far as my cursory glance at wikipedia has informed me, the act itself works around the “plausible deniability” by requiring certain disclosures containing factual information be signed off by key executive staff rendering it impossible for them to say “I didn’t know!” with regards to specific material information.

The blanket concept of holding executive staff accountable for the wrongdoings of the company would mean a lot more disclosures, forms, sign offs, etc. for “any” eventuality that would render the position pointless as they wouldn’t have any time to actually do anything useful.

Because at the end of the day how do you prove that joe schmoe CEO actually fostered a culture that resulted in criminal acts? This isn’t even mentioning the individuals who were actually involved and directly culpable.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: