Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Never had this happen, this is largely eliminated by using tools like black or other autoformatters.


I feel that the main point still stands, though. Saying that Python doesn't have a whitespace problem because you can send the code through a tool that detects whitespace-related problems still acknowledges the existence of said problem.


The point still stands that this is an inherit possibility in the language it self.


Well, in C the visual indentation and the meaning of the code (given by {}) can diverge. That's even worse, and happens in practice. Many style guidelines for C have evolved specifically to address that problem with 'the language itself'.


> Well, in C the visual indentation and the meaning of the code (given by {}) can diverge.

How?


The compiler doesn't check your indentation at all. (OK, not true, these days you get warnings for misleading indentation.) But here's an example of misleading indentation in C:

    if(some condition)
        do something; {
        do something else;
    }
    do another thing;
You can stretch 'some condition' out over multiple lines and have some more parents inside of it, to make it more confusing.

See also https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/a/16530


I see.

Yes

I class that as a bug in the original C specification


But you either make visual indentation significant, or you risk having a discrepancy between visual indentation and what the language sees.


> But you either make visual indentation significant...

That would be Python. I do not like it, which does not mean it is bad, it is a matter of taste

The alternative is you say "blocks are delimited by {}"

`if(foo) bar` should be invalid

`if(foo){bar}` is OK by me. Worik's tick of approval

(Neither is valid C I think)


> That would be Python.

Not necessarily. In practice, in C-as-actually-used people (should) set up linters and formatters, so that you can rely on indentation.

When programming, this means that you can behave as if both curly braces and indentation are significant, and you get an error when they are out-of-sync.


I think its more of an tooling issue. If your editor / diff viewer cant differentiate between different whitespaces get a better one. Also if you want to ensure some function isnt in local scope etc just test it.


And/or linters.

This issue is no worse that having multiple different variables that look the same and only in their obscure same-looking unicode symbols.

A linter can handle this. As can a decent font, or editor settings.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: