Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's strange that Geller got so much pushback. The only truly negative thing he did was suing Randi.

I think Derren Brown has more believers than Geller for his mentalist acts, incorporates "dark demonic forces" and in general messes far more with the minds of his audience. Yet hardly any pushback from Penn and Teller.

Regarding the billet work: Yes, he also goes in shopping malls and "guesses" the correct amount of coins people have in their wallets. The easiest explanation is that he pickpockets them, counts the cash, puts the wallet back and then approaches his target.



Derren Brown doesn’t claim to have superpowers, he’s an illusionist and mentalist. It’s possible he is dishonest about his methods, but he is honest about being an illusionist.

In contrast, Geller has tried to bamboozle the world that he is genuinely psychic, and has other ‘abilities’ and is simply a huckster.

I’m not sure why it would be strange in this instance that one gets pushback from rationalists and one does not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: