The Mozilla issue is labeled as "Position: Positive" and there is a comment that says:
> We're supportive of View Transitions, but since it's a new capability for MPAs in particular, we think it's important that the solution works well for MPAs and that it's consistent with the solution for SPAs. As such, if design changes are needed for the MPA use case that also affect SPA API, the latter should be updated as appropriate even though it has shipped. In other words, we think it would be bad for the SPA and MPA APIs to diverge or be inconsistent.
I don't think that's undecided. More like, "positive with some reservations".
edit: When I think about it again, perhaps you are right given the issue is still open (but also "ready to add").
edit2: Thinking about it more, I like the open process and all but perhaps such discourse should be private before being finalized as early commenters from Mozilla can have a premature influence on public opinion.
> but perhaps such discourse should be private before being finalized as early commenters from Mozilla can have a premature influence on public opinion.
No, it shouldn't. It's a good thing all discussion is happening in the open. See how Firefox devs still have their reservations but Chrome already shipped it to prod completely ignoring any such reservations.
> We're supportive of View Transitions, but since it's a new capability for MPAs in particular, we think it's important that the solution works well for MPAs and that it's consistent with the solution for SPAs. As such, if design changes are needed for the MPA use case that also affect SPA API, the latter should be updated as appropriate even though it has shipped. In other words, we think it would be bad for the SPA and MPA APIs to diverge or be inconsistent.
I don't think that's undecided. More like, "positive with some reservations".
edit: When I think about it again, perhaps you are right given the issue is still open (but also "ready to add").
edit2: Thinking about it more, I like the open process and all but perhaps such discourse should be private before being finalized as early commenters from Mozilla can have a premature influence on public opinion.