Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Died: 7 September 1990 (aged 50–51)

Odd how this part often gets ignored when his example is cited.



Well, he lived for a long time at >200kg (>450lbs), and lost over 120kg (270lbs).

It's not a surprise that his lifespan was shorter than average.

Given his death was a quarter of a century after he finished his fast, I'm not sure it makes the causal implication you are suggesting.


https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21673486

Allegedly health problems from obesity and stomach bleeding killed him. Questionably related to the fast,probably related to the health problems that got him to do the fast in the forst place.


> It's not a surprise that his lifespan was shorter than average.

Given all of the purported health benefits of fasting I see touted on HN, and given how long he fasted, if anything I'd expect him to have lived to 100.


Well he would have if he didn't start eating again.


That was 25 years after his fast, but there have been other cases with complications

E.g. one lady (1st case in the lnk below) who fasted for 4 months ended up in the hospital for 3 weeks with cardiac arrhythmias and they also found her heart tissue muscles were scared and filled with holes (I believe thats what vacuolated means)

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1238550/pdf/wes...

I'm a fan of a 7 day prolonged fast, but not for anything longer


Without any cause listed dying at 50-51 is not rare at all and should not be assumed to be related to a particular cause. In fact, life expectancy of those born on 1940 was 60.8 years, making it within 10 year of the average, something totally normal IMHO (it's like today, with a 78-year life expectancy, someone dying at 68 years old, totally not surprising).


Life expectancy is a tricky stat. One of those cases where mean vs median vs mode is really important. Especially when talking about a period anchored in a global conflict with vast civilian casualties.


25 years after the fast. Are you implying fasting reduces lifespan? Because that would be an hilariously first world concept.

"Remember, to be healthy you need to have 5 small meals during the day. Don't let yourself get hungry," cry the Western dieticians.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: