Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A dash sensor on a police cruiser that would trigger a traffic stop would be wonderful.


Ah yes, just what we need. Another tool the police can use to pull people over. What could possibly go wrong?


I'd like to see traffic enforcement separated from crime enforcement, in the same way we do with parking enforcement, code enforcement, etc. No one really worries about these forms of law enforcement.

There's no reason a guy with a rifle in the trunk and a bullet proof vest needs to spend most of their day dealing with minor traffic code things on the highway.

I would much rather armed cops be much better trained, and much fewer in number, and only activated on the rare occasion that there is a need for them. Traffic cops should be better trained on things like headlight aiming, illegal lift kits and tire modifications, exhaust rules etc...

Most places already have plenty of laws around these things (many of them federal) but cops will never go after someone for having a dangerously lifted truck with illegal exhaust for some reason, even though they are happy to cite someone for a burnt out license plate bulb.


The worst part about this crap is that back in "the day" (so like 70yr ago and before) stops (both of pedestrians and motorists) were known to be discretionary and treated as such. If an officer exercised poor discretion that was a legitimate gripe you could air in court. Now with all the laws everyone violates all the time over the course of being a normal person and behaving normally they have a pretext with which to justify any stop they want.


If you don't want to be busted for a secret crime, don't do a public crime?


This would be fine if policing didn't treat having the wrong skin color as a crime.


Would they actually execute, though? They don't for speeders. And i define speeding here as ~4mph+-speed_limit. Not that i'm advocating pulling people over for "speeding" 5mph, but i often imagine cops allow 9mph without a glance because it allows them to pull over anyone for speeding.

I fear adding yet more rules they don't enforce just adds tools to a questionable toolbag.

I'd love for things like this to be enforced, though. Often feels like the roadways are a warzone heh.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: