Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Schneier on Obama Discussing Security Trade-Offs (schneier.com)
15 points by saikat on Oct 27, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


Schneier has purged all purely political comments, restricting the thread to discussion of security trade-offs only.

I wish that more people in charge of blogs and discussion sites maintained a focus like that: While Slashdot's anything-goes discussions have their place, so do focused conversations in which irrelevancies aren't allowed to intrude.


It is a little funny though to write a post praising Obama, and then ban all political comments.


The ability to understand and explain the 'big picture' of security that Obama displays in this comment is certainly confidence inspiring. To me, at least!


Unfortunately, Schneier is not a security expert, just a layman. He's a mathematician who somehow believes he's qualified to talk about a wide range of security topics. He's not.


Name anyone else who is similarly (or more) qualified that started writing about complicated security issues that laymen and management can understand.


For that matter, name anyone else who expects the Spanish Inquisition.


There is no one. But that doesn't mean Bruce is qualified. An English prof could start writing about security, but it doesn't mean he's qualified.


"DH1. Ad Hominem." "What does he know, he's just a mathematician!"

If you disagree with his thoughts on the matter, feel free to share your low opinion of him, but do try to back it up with real reasoning.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: