Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The model X is also probably one of the most profitable and iconic cars in the modern era.


I'd argue in spite of its doors. A long-range EV in the most popular segment, a full decade before a single competitor? That thing could have had a single door on the front, like the BMW Isetta, and it still would have sold like mad.


Do you have any evidence for "most profitable" at all?

Looks-wise, it's basically indistinguishable from a Model 3 (which are everywhere), so hardly iconic in any way.


It is pulled out of his butt, the F150 sells 3/4 of a million a year (just the f150!) and makes on the low end a gross profit of $10k per sold. The model x sold about 7.5k cars in 2021, way down from the 20-30k it was selling each year.

OK let's say it sold $30k, and Tesla made a profit of $100k (more than the car sells for) for each car.

That's still less than 50% of the F150 yearly profit. LOL.


Comparing it to the F150 is idiotic. That's the most sold car in the US and in a different segment.

Compare it to other comparable cars in the same segment and it looks pretty damn good.

Lower volume high margin cars are really worth it for companies and Ford wishes it had an EV in that classed that sold have as well. The Model X sells in numbers not unlike Mach E while having double the price.


>most profitable and iconic cars in the modern era.

That's what the parent said. Not "in the EV market segment", not "looks pretty damn good".

I agree it's a silly comparison to make normally, but it's a perfectly apt reply to someone stating something so obviously out-of-touch, like the Model X being the most profitable car in the modern era.


They said the most profitable car! I know it isn't a good comparison, I'm just saying what they are saying isn't true.

The profit MARGIN of the model x is great tho.


I assumed he meant margin.

In terms of total profit, the Model Y will be the most profitable car next year, overtaking the F150.


You sure? The model x that sells like 10-30k cars a year is the MOST PROFITABLE CAR IN THE MODERN ERA?

When compared to cars like the F150 that bring in literally billions of dollars in profit a year?

Are you sure?

Oh, you're going to say you weren't counting trucks ;) Mercedes, BMW, Lexus still blow Tesla out of the water with their lineup.


Iconic? To my eyes it's corporate memphis in car form.


I'm sure it's actually the least successful vehicle Tesla sells.


Its comparable in sales to the Model S I think. Maybe even outsells it in some places. And sells more then many other cars in that category.


Looks like it outsold the S for a couple of years (2019-2020?)

https://cleantechnica.com/2021/07/03/tesla-model-3-model-y-m...


Because the base model is $120,000.

A model 3, the budget/everyman car is $40k, and the Model Y is almost $70k.


Isn’t it their worst performing model?


By number of sales it's a wash between it and the S. Which are both low volume, high margin, luxury vehicles. Their high volume vehicles, the 3 and the Y drastically out-sell them naturally.

However the X and the S have very high margins in all configurations so they bring in an outsized amount of profit given their share of sales.

That said the margins on the Model 3/Y are nothing to snuff at and are superior to any other mass market vehicle.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: