Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Fair Use of Ideas (davidbarnard.com)
2 points by joshuacc on Aug 8, 2011 | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments


This article exhibits an unhealthy hidden assumption: that ideas (or maybe concepts) can be owned. That may be true legally, but it isn't true ethically or practically.

Independent invention happens all the time, and basically upends the concept of "idea as property". Wbo invented the computer? Babbage, Turing, Atanasoff or Eckert and Mauchly? Who invented radio? Marcon, Lee de Forest? Who invented the telegraph? Did Morse invent anything that Claude Chappe did not?

Since ideas can be developed independently (Knuth-Morris-Pratt string search, anyone?) and since one inventor really can't tell if someone else "stole" the idea or invented it independently (that is, there's no possession involved), then "stealing" really isn't the proper concept to apply.


Your comments make a lot of sense for certain classes of ideas, like inventions. However, it is less clear to me that they apply to other sorts of "ideas as property," like musical compositions, novels, poetry, etc.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: