Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on the iPad.


(You didn't ask me personally, but here are mine)

I bought the original iPhone on day one (my upgrade from the original Motorola Razr). I vociferously read about technology and gadgets, but am rarely compelled to act on my consumer desires unless I feel like I'm 'gaming' the system by buying at the optimum time and also by defeating the endless upgrade cycle prompts.

I succumbed last year and purchased an iPad while on holiday in The States (ostensibly because of the cheaper price compared to the UK and because my wife wanted to watch Mad Men on vacation).

In truth it was because even though the iPad just seemed to be an enlarged iPod Touch, Apple had certainly hit a home run with the (dare I say it) 'revolutionary' first iPhone, and I wanted to see what the fuss was about.

It immediately made my first generation iPhone obsolete for kicking back at home and mucking about on a touch-screen device, but it certainly wasn't a revolutionary device. It really was just a scaled-up less-portable (read: less useful) version of the original iPhone.

I got an iPhone 4 for christmas and it's a beautiful upgrade from iPhone 1. And it immediately relegated the iPad to 'sitting on the shelf' status in our flat.

This promo video, however teaser/vaporware-like it is, has me rethinking my current reliance on the Apple ecosystem.

It's feels a bit revolutionary... like the first iPhone. A re-imagining of on OS specifically designed for the new form factor. The iPad OS isn't that beast... Apple were first to market with a credible tablet because the initial iPhone OS, albeit upscaled, did a passable job.

For the first time in years, I'm interested in my next device being outside the Apple Walled City.


To be honest, I think you can get my general opinion of the iPad from my original comment. But in one line, an excellently realized product that doesn't really fit my particular pipe dream for a tablet.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: