Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The question is how you organize the albums, hierarchically. The easy case is when you have artist/album/track, like:

Music > Buckethead > Enter The Chicken > Funbus

But how do you file, say, classical music? Do I file this album under Wilhelm Furtwängler, the conductor? Do I file this under Bach and Beethoven, the conductors of various tracks? Do I file this under Wiener Philharmoniker?

In iTunes it’s irrelevant, because I can find the album by looking for Composer=Bach, Composer=Beethoven, artist=Wilhelm Furtwaengler, or artist=Wiener Philharmoniker. With a filesystem I would… use symlinks or something?



Beethoven goes under Beethoven. No one groups stuff by orchestra.

And just because a media player respects your filesystem doesn't mean you can't search by the metadata in the Mp3s. This is extra-helpful when you realize not all Mp3s have metadata. In that case, such search routines will just pass it by.


But filing it under Beethoven means that the album is split apart. This doesn’t make sense to me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: