Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think one key takeaway which isn't directly mentioned in the article is that UX designers, especially on custom-built business solutions like this one, tend to have a pretty rigid concept of the user flow. But the most useful and time-tested pieces of software tend to be the most flexible; the ones that empower users to do what they want, when they want, on-the-fly. That's what's so powerful about a whiteboard; not the fact that it isn't software. They're infinitely flexible and easy to manipulate.

Excel is an (eghem) excellent example of this concept in software, as pointed out by another commenter here. It doesn't presume a particular flow or even a particular set of user stories. It gives you the tools to record and manipulate large amounts of data, no matter what it is or what shape it's in, without writing code. That's a powerful concept and one that more designers should keep in mind.



Another beautiful example is Trello. I've used several task trackers for software projects, Jira and Mantis several times, and my experience with Trello beats everything else.

Turns out, you don't really need complicated automated processes and different views for the same data (as abstractions lover in me was absolutely sure of). Doing task management manually and easily changing workflows on the fly is much more useful.


No, it turns out you didn’t need anything more complicated. Others do (or like it)


Heck, this exact use case probably could have been served with a clever spreadsheet


The UI looked very much like a cross between a spreadsheet and a music sequencer.


To me it looked like they aught to just be running google calendar on an iPad or something.


> Excel is an (eghem) excellent example of this concept in software

Excel is indeed an excellent example, and excellent software. On a related note, pivot tables must be the next best invention after the spreadsheet itself.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: