Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've read Krishnamurthy and frankly it is hard to tell how much of his output is genuine spiritual insight instead of Theosophic hand-me-down.

One thing is for sure, his images in old age (at least to me) convey a melancholic doubt as opposed to the expected beatific enlightened soul. YMMV.



The mind of a motivated seeker tends to be tormented. Perhaps melancholic doubt is a significant brain chemistry upgrade.


Seeker, sure. Guru, no.

[p.s.]

The Sufi master Attar [1] wrote an entire book [2] -- using the symbol of "flyers" or "birds" -- describing the stages of seekers' path to enlightenment. The mataphor used was 'seven valleys of love' [3] encountered on the way to the 'King of the Birds', each with their own distinct psyho-spiritual state and requirements.

The journey has stages but for some there is a 'successful' end.

"If he who sets out on this way will not engage himself wholly and completely he will never be free from the sadness and melancholy which weigh him down."

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attar_of_Nishapur

[2]: "Expression-Logic of the Birds" aka "Conference of the Birds" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Conference_of_the_Birds

[3]: http://chippit.tripod.com/seven_valleys.html


An alternative perspective is that "meta-okayness" might be a goal to aim for. Can I be fundamentally OK even when I don't feel OK? Could I be OK with depression? Could I be OK with sadness? Could I be OK with being human?

Maybe instead of needing to be more enlightened, I just need a nap?


On a personal level "to thine own self be true". Definitely.

But if you are "depressed", "sad", and "don't feel OK" and rather take a "nap" instead of striving for enlightenment, you shouldn't go around giving talks on spiritual matters as a "teacher".


Little of what he taught came from the Theosophical Society, he broke with them relatively early in his life.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: