Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There's a class of wealthy people they can tap into.


Numbers?

Plus at societal scale "wealth" doesn't necessarily work the way it does at the personal level. I can go to the gas pump and buy as much gas as I could personally want at the price posted on the sign. You'll find that if you stepped out and tried to buy ten billion gallons of gas at that price that the situation will change in numerous ways. Confiscating the "wealth" of the rich and trying to use it to buy things that nobody is even making right now is not something you can casually assume will work; the economy itself will need time to adjust before it could even supply the desired goods at such a different scale.

The point here being not that it's impossible, or even undesirable, but merely that naively taking stock of what "the wealthy" have by current measures and assuming you can confiscate arbitrary amounts of it and use it to buy arbitrary amounts of consumer goods without having to account for any of the prices of the goods involved in that operation changing in the process isn't effective.


India's nominal GDP is $1,820 per person.


Which is a lot more than $240.


You gotta be careful of the Laffer Curve[0] though. Tap into the rich too much and they'll leave. Make it illegal to leave... well, your country is going downhill fast.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve


"You gotta be careful of the Laffer Curve[0] though. Tap into the rich too much and they'll leave."

We should tap into it on a global scale. We'll have Moon colonies in no time!


They won't leave if it costs them access to the hugely profitable domestic market that makes them rich.


What is the revenue-maximizing rate of taxation under the Laffer curve?


About 70% of income, according to estimates. It varies for other taxes (capital, consumption, etc.).

Source article: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304393211...


The exact value is near impossible to pinpoint, but you can find it by gradient methods. One thing for certain is that it's lower than the rate I currently pay. ;-)


the laffer curve and supply side economics is junk/propoganda masquerading as economics. It's about as real as the scientific studies exxon releases against global warming.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: