Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | 2461001642's commentslogin

a: mind blown b: isn't this a terrible UX? I mean, these features are GREAT but unless I randomly caught this comment in an HN thread, I would never have known about them. And when I option-click an icon, I have no idea what's going to happen before I do it. (Incidentally, I have the same problems with 3D Touch).


This is an excellent point - kind of goes against my earlier comment. Maybe they have to move this way because that's their only choice - if they don't move into automating this, containers will disrupt them (or already has)


I love the Chef ppl, but...

Is it just me or are there a ton of other folks doing this? The idea of introducing yet another layer of stuff is scary, and there's lots of work left to do on Chef. In a lot of ways, they feel just like Nomad (coincidentally also on the front page)... I wish they would spend some time on their core products versus expanding into an overfilled market.


That's what I thought, too. Chef (software/ecosystem) needs a bit more love IMHO.

However it shows that Chef (Company) is still able to design, build and ship a new product, as an organization. That's a very positive sign. Until recently I thought when comparing Chef with Hashicorp: Hashicorp is so much faster in building and releasing usable stuff but they seem to feel the pain in growing too fast and too broad in terms of products.

So, in the end: It's a great thing, just also don't forget to put more love into Chef (software) and don't dissipate developers/time/budget :)


Thanks for responding! Can you say how you deal with the significant latencies over multiple AZs?

Also, would you mind answering my other question about whether or not I can run Marathon or Chronos against ECS since it runs Mesos under the hood?


Can you elaborate on the intra- inter-* latencies your are seeing? for AZ independent services this should single digits.


When I'm balancing a single deployment across multiple AZs (e.g. US-East -> US-West), the latencies between the containers seem far higher than just the 200-300ms predicted by speed of light. Am I doing something wrong?


No mesos under the hood. You can bring mesos as your own scheduler.


Thanks again - this is really helpful. I had talked to someone who had left Amazon but knew the internal workings who said ECS was Mesos just privately branded like Chef -> OpsWorks, but I guess I must have misunderstood.

Thanks for clarifying!


I've heard that it just runs Mesos under the hood, how does this differ than me running Mesos on my own? Can I run Chronos or Marathon against it?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: