Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | mathewsanders's favoriteslogin

One thing that I think people need to understand is the distinction between science and the practice of medicine.

The practice of medicine is not science. The practice of medicine can be informed by science - to a degree that is almost entirely up to the practitioner. ; but it remains more art than science. The distinction is similar to that between an aviation maintenance and aerospace engineering.

Sometimes doctors are just out of their depth.



USSR style communism was really an authoritarian dictatorship.

In capitalist west, capitalism was also about distribution of goods but literally being nice about it. Working together.

The language is meaningless gibberish. The tone and emotional spin, roleplay are what’s important.

In the US we’re enabling iron fisted oligarchs like the USSR once had. Those who refuse to share without extreme deference and idolatry, not because they’re that important to the well being of billions (they’re not) but because they’re important to the political actors that insulate them from taxation.


Chekhov Gun discussions always remind me of this Vonnegut passage:

"I had no respect whatsoever for the creative works of either the painter or the novelist. I thought Karabekian with his meaningless pictures had entered into a conspiracy with millionaires to make poor people feel stupid. I thought Beatrice Keedsler had joined hands with other old-fashioned storytellers to make people believe that life had leading characters, minor characters, significant details, insignificant details, that it had lessons to be learned, tests to be passed, and a beginning, a middle, and an end.

"As I approached my fiftieth birthday, I had become more and more enraged and mystified by the idiot decisions made by my countrymen. And then I had come suddenly to pity them, for I understood how innocent and natural it was for them to behave so abominably, and with such abominable results: They were doing their best to live like people invented in story books. This was the reason Americans shot each other so often: It was a convenient literary device for ending short stories and books."

(from Breakfast of Champions, by an author who often tells you the end in the beginning and puts the journey in the details)


Much more interesting is the other way. Contemporary highly respected artists, lauded by critics, who couldn't stand the test of time. Rightfully though. Critics often have their darlings for whatever reasons, only remotely concerning their actual work. If it's political criticism, contemporary humor or other events.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: